Approval workflow software: 9 options compared

The right approval tool depends on what is being approved and where your people already work. If you run Microsoft 365, a product built on SharePoint keeps approvals next to your documents. For finance only, a tool made for invoices may be enough. For complex, cross-system processes, look at the larger workflow platforms.

Get help choosing approval workflow software

500+projects delivered
350+clients across 15+ industries
15+years building on Microsoft

Method

How we compared them

Every option is described the same way, so you can read across and see the differences quickly.

  • What we looked atHow each tool builds approvals, how routing and escalation work, how much it connects to documents and finance systems, and who it suits.
  • The same five points for eachWhat it is, strengths, what to check before you buy, deployment, and who it suits best.
  • Where the facts come fromEach vendor’s own product descriptions, as the vendors state them. Vendors change products and editions, so confirm details with them before you buy.
  • Prices and scoresWe leave out prices and scores. Prices change often and many vendors quote by user count, so ask each shortlisted vendor for a written quote.
  • Who wrote itAscenWork’s consultants. We have built on SharePoint and Microsoft 365 since 2010, and we cover the wider market here so you can compare like with like.
At a glance

Approval workflow software compared: side by side

9 options, grouped by type. Deployment is as described by each vendor.

ToolBest forDeployment
AscenWork Approval Workflow (Built on Microsoft 365)Organisations on Microsoft 365 that want to replace email approvals with a configured system.Installed in your own Microsoft 365 tenant. Your data stays in your SharePoint.
M-Files (Document and content platforms)Approvals that belong to documents, such as policies, contracts and quality records.Cloud, on premises or hybrid.
Nintex (Workflow and process platforms)Larger organisations with complex approval logic and a need for governance and integrations.Cloud, with on-premises options in older server products. Ask which applies to the edition you are quoted.
ProcessMaker (Workflow and process platforms)Structured, rule-heavy processes at enterprise scale.Cloud or on premises.
Kissflow (Workflow and process platforms)HR, finance, procurement and operations teams that want to build approvals without developers.Cloud (SaaS).
Zoho Creator (Low-code and no-code builders)Small and growing organisations, especially those already on Zoho.Cloud.
Pipefy (Low-code and no-code builders)Operations and service teams that manage requests as a queue.Cloud.
ApprovalMax (Finance approvals)Finance and accounting teams that need clear control over spend approvals.Cloud.
monday.com (Low-code and no-code builders)Teams that already run projects and tasks on monday.com and need simple approvals.Cloud.

The 9 options

Each option in detail

The same five points for every option. Use the filter to see one type, and the button on a card if you want help weighing that option.

How this list works: the order is our own choice and cannot be bought. A vendor marked Sponsored has paid for a listing, and its entry is written to the same five points as every other. AscenWork sells one of the products listed, so we put it first and say plainly where it does not fit.

  1. Built on Microsoft 365

    AscenWork Approval Workflow

    A ready-made approval product that runs on SharePoint Online inside your own Microsoft 365.

    A product we configure to your process. Requests are routed to the right approvers, each step is timed, and every decision is kept in a history.

    • Your Microsoft 365

    Strengths

    • Ready templates for document, purchase, leave, invoice, IT access and contract approvals.
    • Routing in sequence or in parallel, across as many levels as needed.
    • Threshold rules that change the approver by value or type.
    • SLA tracking that shows which approvals are waiting.
    • A complete history of decisions.

    Check before you buy

    It runs on Microsoft 365 and SharePoint Online only, so it suits organisations that already use them. Changes beyond the standard product are quoted separately.

    Deployment

    Installed in your own Microsoft 365 tenant. Your data stays in your SharePoint.

    Best for: Organisations on Microsoft 365 that want to replace email approvals with a configured system.

    See the product
  2. Document and content platforms

    M-Files

    Approvals that follow a document through its life, driven by what the document is.

    A document management platform that classifies content by metadata and moves it through workflow states such as draft, review and approved.

    • Cloud
    • On premises
    • Hybrid

    Strengths

    • Workflow tied to document state.
    • Metadata-led organisation instead of folders.
    • Search by content and context.
    • Compliance and lifecycle control for controlled documents.

    Check before you buy

    The metadata model needs planning before roll-out. It is a separate platform to buy and learn, even though it connects to Microsoft 365.

    Deployment

    Cloud, on premises or hybrid.

    Best for: Approvals that belong to documents, such as policies, contracts and quality records.

  3. Workflow and process platforms

    Nintex

    A broad process automation platform for complex, governed approvals.

    A platform for building workflows with drag-and-drop forms and business logic, with add-ons for e-signature, document generation, process mapping and robotic process automation.

    • Cloud
    • On premises

    Strengths

    • Forms with business logic.
    • Mobile apps with embedded workflows.
    • E-signature and document generation in the same family.
    • Connectors to other systems and a framework for custom connectors.
    • Process monitoring.

    Check before you buy

    It is a family of products, so confirm which ones and which edition your use case needs. Licensing and set-up can be heavy for simple approvals.

    Deployment

    Cloud, with on-premises options in older server products. Ask which applies to the edition you are quoted.

    Best for: Larger organisations with complex approval logic and a need for governance and integrations.

  4. Workflow and process platforms

    ProcessMaker

    Business process management with approvals as one of its patterns.

    A platform for modelling processes in BPMN and running them with rule-based approvals, reporting and system integrations.

    • Cloud
    • On premises

    Strengths

    • Process modelling with BPMN.
    • Rule-based approval routing.
    • Reporting and analytics on how processes run.
    • Integration with other systems.

    Check before you buy

    Modelling processes well takes skill and time. For a handful of simple approvals it may be more than you need.

    Deployment

    Cloud or on premises.

    Best for: Structured, rule-heavy processes at enterprise scale.

  5. Workflow and process platforms

    Kissflow

    A no-code workflow builder aimed at business teams, with enterprise controls.

    A cloud platform where business users design approval forms and flows visually, while IT keeps control of publishing and integrations.

    • Cloud

    Strengths

    • Sequential and parallel approvals.
    • Conditional routing by amount, department or request type.
    • Approvers can approve, reject or send back.
    • SLA escalation.
    • Audit trails.
    • Connectors to common business systems, including Microsoft 365.
    • The vendor lists data residency options in several regions.

    Check before you buy

    It is cloud only, so it does not suit data that must stay on your own network. Check that its connectors cover your finance and HR systems.

    Deployment

    Cloud (SaaS).

    Best for: HR, finance, procurement and operations teams that want to build approvals without developers.

  6. Low-code and no-code builders

    Zoho Creator

    A low-code builder for custom business apps with approval rules built in.

    A platform for building business applications, where approvals are set up per module with approvers chosen by name, role or hierarchy.

    • Cloud

    Strengths

    • Approval rules by module, role and hierarchy.
    • Automatic email alerts on approval or rejection.
    • Scripting for custom actions.
    • Connections to CRMs, payment gateways, databases and APIs.

    Check before you buy

    Custom logic needs scripting in Zoho’s own language. It fits best when the rest of your tools are Zoho too, and your approval data lives in Zoho.

    Deployment

    Cloud.

    Best for: Small and growing organisations, especially those already on Zoho.

  7. Low-code and no-code builders

    Pipefy

    Approvals run as cards moving through the phases of a pipeline.

    A cloud platform that organises work into pipelines with phases, forms, automation rules and service level tracking.

    • Cloud

    Strengths

    • Pipelines that show where every request is.
    • Rule-based automation between phases.
    • SLA monitoring.
    • Analytics on how long each phase takes.

    Check before you buy

    The pipeline model suits hand-offs between teams better than document-centred approvals. Check how deep its integrations go with your existing systems.

    Deployment

    Cloud.

    Best for: Operations and service teams that manage requests as a queue.

  8. Finance approvals

    ApprovalMax

    Made for approving invoices, purchase orders and payments.

    A cloud tool that adds approval control to finance work, with audit-ready records of who approved what.

    • Cloud

    Strengths

    • Approval of invoices, purchase orders and payments.
    • Audit logs and activity tracking.
    • Compliance controls for finance teams.

    Check before you buy

    It focuses on finance approvals. It is not a general tool for leave, access or document approvals. Check that your accounting system is supported.

    Deployment

    Cloud.

    Best for: Finance and accounting teams that need clear control over spend approvals.

  9. Low-code and no-code builders

    monday.com

    Team work management with rule-based automation for simple approvals.

    A cloud work management platform where boards, dashboards and automations can handle basic approval steps.

    • Cloud

    Strengths

    • Rule-based automations on boards.
    • Visual dashboards.
    • Integrations through an API.
    • Easy for teams already managing work there.

    Check before you buy

    Approvals are lightweight, so complex multi-level routing, audit needs or document control may need another tool.

    Deployment

    Cloud.

    Best for: Teams that already run projects and tasks on monday.com and need simple approvals.

Choosing

Which one to look at first

Match what you approve and where your people work, then ask two or three vendors for a written quote.

If this is youStart by looking atWhy
Your people work in Microsoft 365 and TeamsA product built on SharePoint, such as AscenWork Approval Workflow, or Power Automate approvalsApprovals stay next to your documents, under the security you already run.
Approvals belong to documents such as policies and contractsM-Files or a SharePoint based productThe workflow follows the document through its states.
Complex, cross-system approvals with strict governanceNintex or ProcessMakerBoth are built for modelled processes, rules and integrations.
Business teams want to build their own flows without developersKissflow or Zoho CreatorBoth offer visual builders for forms and approval routing.
You manage requests as a queue between teamsPipefyPipelines show where every request sits and how long it waited.
You only need to approve invoices, purchase orders and paymentsApprovalMaxIt is focused on finance approvals with audit-ready records.
Before you decide

Five questions to settle before you compare tools

Answering these first makes every demo and quote easier to judge.

What exactly gets approved?

List the request types: documents, purchases, leave, invoices, access. A tool that suits one type may not suit another.

How many levels, and what changes the route?

Write down who approves what, in what order, and which values or request types send it to someone else.

What must you prove later?

Decide what the audit trail must show: who approved, when, with what comment, and what changed.

What happens when someone does not respond?

Ask each vendor to show reminders, escalation and delegation for absences, not just describe them.

Where must the data live?

Some data must stay on your network or in your Microsoft 365. Decide this early, because not every tool offers every option.

Frequently asked questions

What is approval workflow software?

It routes a request, such as a purchase, a leave application or a document, to the right people in the right order, records each decision and reminds people who have not responded. It replaces approvals by email.

Can Power Automate handle approvals?

Yes. Power Automate includes approval actions, and approvers can respond by email or in the approvals centre. It becomes a managed system when the routing rules, templates, reporting and history are designed up front, which is the work a configured product does for you.

How is a ready-made approval product different from a platform?

A platform gives you a builder, and you design every flow. A ready-made product starts with templates and rules for common approvals, so you configure rather than build. Platforms suit unusual processes, products suit common ones.

What should an approval workflow record?

The requester, each approver, the time of each step, the decision, any comment and any change to the request. That record is what you show an auditor.

Do I need a separate tool for invoice approvals?

Not always. Some tools are made only for finance approvals. If you need leave, access and document approvals as well, a general approval tool can cover them all, as long as it connects to your finance system.

How much does approval software cost?

Prices vary by users, modules and deployment, and most are quoted. We show none here. Ask each shortlisted vendor for a written quote that lists what is included and what costs extra.

Talk to us

Not sure which approval tool fits?